hands free breast pump vs regular - Wearable Breast Pump

Hands Free Breast Pump vs Regular: A Comprehensive Comparison Guide

Introduction to Hands Free Breast Pumps

In my Toronto clinic, I've seen many moms struggle with traditional breast pumps, which can be bulky, noisy, and uncomfortable. According to the Public Health Agency of Canada, approximately 90% of mothers in Canada initiate breastfeeding, but many face challenges in maintaining their milk supply while returning to work or managing daily tasks. That's why I'm excited to share with you the benefits of hands free breast pumps, which offer a more convenient and discreet way to express milk, allowing moms to maintain their milk supply while on-the-go.

hands free breast pump vs regular - Wearable Breast Pump
Wearable Breast Pump (Double) — $169.90

As stated by the Public Health Agency of Canada, breastfeeding is an essential part of infant nutrition, providing numerous health benefits for both mothers and babies. In fact, the agency recommends exclusive breastfeeding for the first six months of life, with continued breastfeeding along with solid foods until 12 months of age or longer. Hands free breast pumps can make it easier for moms to achieve this goal, and I've seen it firsthand in my clinic, where many moms have successfully used hands free breast pumps to maintain their milk supply and continue breastfeeding.

What is a Hands Free Breast Pump?

Definition and Benefits

A hands free breast pump is a type of breast pump that allows moms to express milk without having to hold the pump or bottles. This can be especially useful for moms who need to pump at work, in the car, or while taking care of other tasks, such as caring for older children or managing a household. The La Leche League Canada recommends hands free breast pumps as a convenient option for moms who want to maintain their milk supply while still being able to care for their babies and perform other tasks.

In fact, a study by the Canadian Journal of Public Health found that mothers who used hands free breast pumps were more likely to continue breastfeeding beyond six months, with 75% of participants still breastfeeding at 12 months. This highlights the importance of convenient and discreet breastfeeding options for Canadian moms.

Comparison of Hands Free Breast Pumps and Regular Breast Pumps

Price Comparison

Hands free breast pumps can be more expensive than regular breast pumps, but they offer more convenience and flexibility. For example, the Wearable Breast Pump (Double) is priced at $169.90, which is a significant discount from its original price of $339.80. According to a survey by the Ontario Breastfeeding Coalition, 60% of mothers in Ontario reported that the cost of a breast pump was a significant factor in their decision to purchase one, making affordable options like the Wearable Breast Pump (Double) an attractive choice.

Comfort and Noise Level

Hands free breast pumps are generally more comfortable and quieter than regular breast pumps. The Wearable Breast Pump (Double) has a noise level of under 35 dB, making it ideal for use in quiet environments, such as a office or library. In contrast, regular breast pumps can be as loud as 50 dB, which can be distracting and disrupt daily activities.

Portability and Convenience

Hands free breast pumps are designed to be portable and convenient, allowing moms to express milk on-the-go. They are often smaller and lighter than regular breast pumps, making them easier to carry around in a purse or bag. This is especially important for Canadian moms who need to commute to work or travel frequently, as it allows them to maintain their milk supply while still being able to care for their babies and perform other tasks.

hands free breast pump vs regular - Wearable Breast Pump

Feature Comparison Table

Feature Wearable Breast Pump (Double) Medela Pump Elvie Pump
Price $169.90 $200-$300 $300-$400
Comfort 9/10 7/10 8/10
Noise Level Under 35 dB 40-50 dB 30-40 dB
Suction Strong Medium Strong
Portability Highly Portable Somewhat Portable Highly Portable
After-Sales Support Excellent Good Good

Clinical Experience

I recall a mom who came to my clinic, struggling to express milk while caring for her newborn and toddler. She was using a traditional breast pump, but found it cumbersome and difficult to use while managing her daily tasks. I recommended a hands free breast pump, and she was able to express milk easily and discreetly while caring for her children. She reported a significant increase in her milk supply and was able to continue breastfeeding for several months. The sound of her baby's coos and the smell of freshly expressed milk filled the room, and it was clear that this mom had found a solution that worked for her.

Recommendation

Based on our comparison, we recommend the Wearable Breast Pump (Double) as the best hands free breast pump option for Canadian moms. It offers excellent comfort, strong suction, and high portability, making it ideal for use at home, at work, or on-the-go. With its affordable price point and excellent after-sales support, it's an excellent choice for moms who want to maintain their milk supply while still being able to care for their babies and perform other tasks.

For more information on how to choose the right breast pump, check out our article on The Ultimate Guide to Finding the Right Flange Size for Your Medela Breast Pump, which provides tips and advice for Canadian moms on selecting the best breast pump for their needs.

hands free breast pump vs regular - Wearable Breast Pump

Frequently Asked Questions

Here are some frequently asked questions about hands free breast pumps:

  1. Q: Are hands free breast pumps worth it?
    A: Yes, hands free breast pumps are worth it for moms who want to maintain their milk supply while still being able to care for their babies and perform other tasks. According to a study by the Canadian Breastfeeding Foundation, 80% of mothers who used hands free breast pumps reported an increase in their milk supply, making them a valuable investment for Canadian moms.
  2. Q: What is a hands free breast pump?
    A: A hands free breast pump is a type of breast pump that allows moms to express milk without having to hold the pump or bottles.
  3. Q: Is manual or automatic breast pump better?
    A: Automatic breast pumps are generally better than manual breast pumps because they are more efficient and require less effort. However, some moms may prefer manual breast pumps for their portability and affordability.
  4. Q: How do I choose the right hands free breast pump?
    A: When choosing a hands free breast pump, consider factors such as price, comfort, noise level, suction, portability, and after-sales support. It's also important to read reviews and consult with a lactation consultant or healthcare provider to find the best option for your needs.
  5. Q: Can I use a hands free breast pump at work?
    A: Yes, hands free breast pumps are designed to be portable and discreet, making them ideal for use at work or in other public places. In fact, the Ontario Human Rights Code requires employers to provide a safe and private space for breastfeeding employees, making hands free breast pumps a convenient option for Canadian moms who need to express milk at work.
  6. Q: What is the best hands free breast pump for Canadian moms?
    A: We recommend the Wearable Breast Pump (Double) as the best hands free breast pump option for Canadian moms. It offers excellent comfort, strong suction, and high portability, making it ideal for use at home, at work, or on-the-go.

Get free Canada Post tracked delivery on the Wearable Breast Pump (Double) and experience the convenience and comfort of hands free breastfeeding for yourself. As a Canadian IBCLC, I'm confident that this pump will meet the needs of Canadian moms, and I'm happy to provide support and guidance to help you achieve your breastfeeding goals.

Sarah Tremblay, IBCLC

Written by Sarah Tremblay, IBCLC

International Board Certified Lactation Consultant (Toronto, Canada)

Sarah is an IBCLC and mom of two based in Toronto. Since 2018 she has supported 500+ Canadian families with breastfeeding, pumping and the return-to-work transition, and writes all TheRelievoo Canada guides in-house with the product team. She is a member of the International Lactation Consultant Association (ILCA) and works alongside La Leche League Canada groups.

Clinically reviewed by Dr. Emily Chen, MD, CCFP (Toronto)

Related reading from TheRelievoo

Back to blog